| United States-latin American Relations |
Article Index for United |
Website Links For United |
Information AboutUnited States-latin American Relations |
| CATEGORIES ABOUT UNITED STATES-LATIN AMERICAN RELATIONS | |
| history of south america | |
| foreign relations of the united states | |
| united states-south american relations | |
|
19TH CENTURY TO WORLD WAR I The 1823 Monroe Doctrine , founder of US Isolationism , theorized the imperative for the US to break with Europe and focus on the continent of America . US Secretary of State James G. Blaine formulated the Big Brother Policy in the 1880s, aiming to rally the Latin America n nations behind US leadership and to open Latin America markets to U.S. traders. Blaine served as Secretary Of State in 1881 in the cabinet of President James Garfield and again from 1889 to 1892 in the cabinet of President Benjamin Harrison . As part of the policy, Blaine arranged for and lead as the first president the First International Conference Of American States in 1889 . A few years later, the Spanish-American War in 1898 provoked the end of the Spanish Empire in the Caribbean and the Pacific , with the 1898 Treaty Of Paris giving the US control over the former Spanish colonies of Puerto Rico , the Philippines and Guam , and control over the process of independence of Cuba , which was completed in 1902 . The Panama Canal , such as this one at Miraflores Locks , are among the largest ships to use the Panama Canal . In October 2006, Panamanian citizens approved by a Wide Margin on a Referendum a Project To Expand the canal.]] Theodore Roosevelt , who became president of the United States in 1901, believed that a U.S.-controlled canal across Central America was a vital strategic interest to the U.S. This idea gained wide impetus following the destruction of the battleship USS ''Maine'' , in Cuba , on February 15 , 1898 . The USS ''Oregon'' , a battleship stationed in San Francisco , was dispatched to take her place, but the voyage — around Cape Horn — took 67 days. Although she was in time to join in the Battle of Santiago Bay, the voyage would have taken just three weeks via Panama. Roosevelt was able to reverse a previous decision by the Walker Commission in favour of a Nicaragua Canal , and pushed through the acquisition of the French Panama Canal effort. Panama was then part of Colombia , so Roosevelt opened negotiations with the Colombians to obtain the necessary permission. In early 1903 the Hay-Herran Treaty was signed by both nations, but the Colombian Senate failed to ratify the treaty. In a controversial move, Roosevelt implied to Panamanian rebels that if they revolted, the U.S. Navy would assist their cause for independence. Panama proceeded to proclaim its independence on November 3 , 1903, and the USS ''Nashville'' in local waters impeded any interference from Colombia (see Gunboat Diplomacy ). The victorious Panamanians returned the favor to Roosevelt by allowing the United States control of the Panama Canal Zone on February 23 , 1904 , for US$ 10 million (as provided in the Hay-Bunau-Varilla Treaty , signed on November 18 , 1903 ). The US president then formulated the Roosevelt Corollary To The Monroe Doctrine , in 1904, which asserted the right of the United States to intervene in Latin American nations' affairs. In its altered state, the Monroe Doctrine would now consider Latin America as an agency for expanding U.S. commercial interests in the region, along with its original stated purpose of keeping European hegemony from the hemisphere. In addition, the corollary proclaimed the explicit right of the United States to intervene in Latin American conflicts exercising an international police power. The Roosevelt Corollary and the Dollar Diplomacy When the Venezuelan government under Cipriano Castro was no longer able to placate the demands of European bankers in 1902, naval forces from Great Britain, Italy, and Germany erected a blockade along the Venezuelan coast and even fired upon coastal fortifications. Though United States Secretary Of State Elihu Root characterized Castro as a "a crazy brute," President Roosevelt was concerned with the prospects of penetration into the region by the German Empire . Roosevelt threatened military action against the European powers, who retreated and later negotiated with Castro. This incident was a major stimulus behind the Roosevelt Corollary and the subsequent U.S. policy of Dollar Diplomacy in Latin America . During the presidency of Juan Vicente Gómez , Petroleum was discovered under Lake Maracaibo . Gómez managed to deflate Venezuela's staggering debt by granting concessions to foreign oil companies, which won him the support of the United States and the European powers. The growth of the domestic oil industry strengthened the economic ties between the U.S. and Venezuela. Banana Wars in Nicaragua in 1932]] At the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century, the US carried on several military interventions in what became known as the Banana Wars . The term arose from the connections between the interventions and the preservation of US commercial interests, starting with the United Fruit corporation, which had significant financial stakes in production of Banana s, Tobacco , Sugar Cane , and various other agricultural products throughout the Caribbean , Central America and the northern portions of South America . North-Americans advocating Imperialism in the pre- World War I era often argued that these conflicts helped central and South Americans by aiding in stability. Some imperialists argued that these limited interventions did not serve US interests sufficiently and argued for expanded actions in the region. Anti-imperialists argued that these actions were a first step down a slippery slope towards US Colonialism in the region. Some modern observers have argued that if World War I had not lessened American enthusiasm for international activity these interventions might have led to the formation of an expanded U.S. colonial empire, with Central American states either annexed into Statehood like Hawaii or becoming American Territories , like the Philippines , Puerto Rico and Guam . This view is, however, heavily disputed, especially as, after a decrease in activity during and after World War I, the U.S. government intervened again in the 1920s while again stating that it was without colonial ambitions. The Banana Wars ended with the 1933 Good Neighbor Policy of President Franklin D. Roosevelt ; no American colonies had been created. The countries involved in the Banana Wars include:
Though many other countries in the region may have been influenced or dominated by American banana or other companies, there is no history of U.S. military intervention during this period in those countries. 1940S-1960S: THE COLD WAR AND THE "HEMISPHERIC DEFENSE" DOCTRINE Officially started in 1947 with the Truman Doctrine theorizing the " Containment " policy, the Cold War had important consequences in Latin America, considered by the United States to be a full part of the Western Bloc, called " Free World ", in contrast with the Eastern Bloc , a division born with the end of World War II and the Yalta Conference (February 1945). It "must be the policy of the United States," Truman declared, "to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or outside pressures." Truman rallied North-Americans to spend $400 million to intervene in the Civil War In Greece , while the CIA (created by the National Security Act Of 1947 ) intervention in this country was its first act of birth. By aiding Greece, Truman set a precedent for U.S. aid to regimes, no matter how repressive and corrupt, that request help to fight communists LaFeber, Walter . ''America, Russia, and the Cold War, 1945–1992'' 7th ed. (1993) . Washington began to sign a series of defense treaties with countries all over the world, including the North Atlantic Treaty of 1949 which created NATO , and the ANZUS in 1951 with Australia and New Zealand. Moscow response to NATO and to the Marshall Plan in Europe included the creation of the COMECON economic treaty and the Warsaw Pact defense alliance, gathering Eastern Europe countries which had fall under its Sphere Of Influence . After the Berlin Blockade by the Soviet Union, the Korean War (1950-53) was one of the first conflicts of the Cold War, while the US would succeed to France in the Counter-revolutionary War against Viet-minh in Indochina . In Latin America itself, the US defense treaty was the Inter-American Treaty Of Reciprocal Assistance (aka Rio Treaty or TIAR) of 1947, known as the "hemispheric defense" treaty. It was the formalisation of the Act of Chapultepec , adopted at the Inter-American Conference on the Problems of War and Peace in 1945 in Mexico City . The US had maintained a hemispheric defense policy under the Monroe Doctrine , and during the 1930s had been alarmed by Axis overtures toward military cooperation with Latin American governments, in particular apparent strategic threats against the Panama Canal . During the war Washington had been able to secure Allied support from all individual governments except Uruguay , which remained neutral, and wished to make those commitments permanent. With the exceptions of Trinidad And Tobago (1967), Belize (1981), and the Bahamas (1982), no countries that became independent after 1947 have joined the treaty. The next year, the Organization Of American States was created in April 1948, during the Ninth International Conference Of American States held in Bogotá and led by U.S. Secretary Of State George Marshall . Members states pledge to Fight Communism in the Americas. 21 American countries signed the Charter Of The Organization Of American States on 30 April 1948 . Operation PBSUCCESS which overthrew the Democratically-elected President of Guatemala , Jacobo Arbenz Guzmán in 1954 was to be one of the first in a long series of US intervention in Latin America during the Cold War. It immediately followed the Overthrow Of Mossadegh in Iran (1953). 1960S: THE CUBAN REVOLUTION AND THE US RESPONSE The 1959 Castro marks Bay of Pigs victory BBC News Each time the Cuban government nationalized American properties, the American government took countermeasures, resulting in the prohibition of all exports to Cuba on October 19 , 1960 . Consequently, Cuba began to consolidate trade Relations With The Soviet Union , leading the US to break off all remaining official diplomatic relations. Later that year, U.S. diplomats Edwin L. Sweet and Wiliam G. Friedman were arrested and expelled from the island having been charged with "encouraging terrorist acts, granting asylum, financing subversive publications and smuggling weapons”. The U.S. began the formulation of new plans aimed at destabilizing the Cuban government, collectively known as the “ The Cuban Project ” (aka Operation Mongoose). This was to be a co-ordinated program of political, psychological, and military sabotage, involving intelligence operations as well as assassination attempts on key political leaders. The Cuban project also proposed False Flag attacks, known as Operation Northwoods . A U.S. Senate Select Intelligence Committee report later confirmed over eight attempted plots to kill Castro between 1960 and 1965, as well as additional plans against other Cuban leaders. Interim Report: Alleged Assassination Plots Involving Foreign Leaders Original document Beside this aggressive policy towards Cuba, President John F. Kennedy tried to implement in 1961 the Alliance For Progress , an economic aid program which proved to be too shy. In the same time, the U.S. suspended economic and/or broke off diplomatic relations with several dictatorships between 1961 and JFK's assassination in 1963, including Argentina, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Peru. But these suspensions were imposed only temporarily, for periods of only three weeks to six months. However, the US finally decided it best to train Latin American militaries in Counter-insurgency tactics at the School Of The Americas . In effect, the Alliance for Progress included U.S. programs of military and police assistance to counter Communism, including Plan LASO in Colombia. The Nuclear Arms Race brought the two superpowers to the brink of nuclear war. In 1962, President John F. Kennedy responded to the installation of nuclear missiles in Cuba with a naval blockade—a show of force that brought the world close to nuclear war. "Cold War," ''Dictionary of the Social Sciences''. Craig Calhoun, ed. Oxford University Press. 2002. The Cuban Missile Crisis showed that neither superpower was ready to use nuclear weapons for fear of the other's retaliation, and thus of Mutually Assured Destruction . The aftermath of the Cuban Missile Crisis led to the first efforts at nuclear disarmament and improving relations. (Palmowski) By 1964, under President Johnson, the program to discriminate against dictatorial regimes ceased. In March 1964 the US approved a military coup in Brazil, overthrowing left-wing president João Goulart , and was prepared to help if called upon under Operation Brother Sam .1 The next year, the US dispatched 24,000 troops to the Dominican Republic to stop a possible left-wing take over under Operation Power Pack . Through the Office Of Public Safety (OPS), an organization dependent of the USAID and close to the CIA, the US assisted Latin American security forces, training them in interrogation methods, riot control, and sending them equipment. Dan Mitrione , in Uruguay, became unfamous for his systemic use of torture. 1970S: THE ERA OF THE JUNTAS Following the 1959 Electronic Briefing Book No. 73 - Part II, CIA classified documents released in 2002 , and then supported the 1980 " Cocaine Coup " of Luis García Meza Tejada in Bolivia, before training the Contras in Nicaragua where the Sandinista National Liberation Front , headed by Daniel Ortega , had taken power in 1979, as well as Militaries In Guatemala and in El Salvador . In the frame of Operation Charly , supported by the US, the Argentine military imported State Terror tactics to Central America, where the "dirty war" was waged until well in the 1990s, making hundreds of thousands " Disappeared ." Placing their own actions within the US doctrine of " National Security " against "internal subversion," the authoritarian regimes who had crushed left-wing opposition began a transition to Neoliberal economic policies. Chile thus became one of the laboratory of Shock Therapy , under the supervision of the Chicago Boys influenced by Milton Friedman 's Monetarism . With the election of President Jimmy Carter in 1979, the US moderated for a short time support to authoritarian regimes in Latin America. It was during this year that the Inter-American Court Of Human Rights , an agency of the OAS, was created. At the same time, voices in North America began to denounce Pinochet's violation of human rights, in particular after the 1976 assassination of former Chilean minister Orlando Letelier in Washington DC. 1980S - 1990S: DEMOCRATIZATION AND THE WASHINGTON CONSENSUS The election of Ronald Reagan in 1981 meant for Latin America a renewed support for right-wing authoritarian regimes. In the 1980s, the situation progressively evolved in the world as in South America, despite a Renewal Of The Cold War from 1979 to 1985, The Year during which Mikhail Gorbachev replaced Konstantin Chernenko as leader of the USSR, and began to implement the Glasnost and the Perestroika democratic-inspired reforms. South America saw various states Returning Progressively To Democracy . This democratization of South America found a symbol in the OAS 's adoption of Resolution 1080 in 1991, which requires the Secretary General to convene the Permanent Council within ten days of a Coup D'état in any member country. However, in the same time, Washington started to aggressively pursue the " War On Drugs ", which included the Invasion Of Panama in 1989 to overthrow Manuel Noriega , who had been a long-time ally of the US and had even worked for the CIA before his reign as leader of the country. The "War on Drugs" was later expanded through Plan Colombia in the late 1990s. Reagan's support of Margaret Thatcher during the 1982 Falklands War against the Military Junta in Argentina also led to a change of relations between Washington and Buenos Aires which had been actively helping Reagan when the Argentine Intelligence Service was training and arming the Nicaraguan Contra s against the Sandinista government ( Operation Charly ). The 601 Intelligence Battalion , for example, trained Contras at Lepaterique base, in Honduras, under the supervision of US ambassador John Negroponte . While the US were fighting against Nicaragua, leading to the 1986 Nicaragua V. United States case before the International Court Of Justice , Washington DC supported authoritarian regimes in Guatemala and Salvador. The support to General Ríos Montt during the Guatemalan Civil War and the alliance with José Napoleón Duarte during the Salvadoran Civil War were legitimized by the Reagan administration as full part of the Cold War, although other allies strongly criticized this assistance to dictatorships (i.e. the French Socialist Party 's 110 Propositions ). In fact, many Latin American countries view the 1982 conflict as a clear example of how the so called ''Hemispheric relations'' works. {Link without Title} A deep weakening of hemispheric relations occurred due to the American support given, without mediation, to the United Kingdom during the Malvinas war in 1982. Some argue this definitively turned the TIAR into a dead letter. In 2001 , the United States invoked the Rio Treaty after the September 11 Attacks but Latin American democracies did not join the '' War On Terror '' actively. (Furthermore, Mexico withdrew from the treaty in 2001 citing the Falklands example.) On the economic plane, hardly affected by the 1973 Oil Crisis , Mexico refusal in 1983 to pay the interest of its Debt led to the Latin American Debt Crisis and subsequently to a shift from the Import Substitution Industrialization (ISA) policies followed by most countries to Export-oriented Industrialization , which was encouraged by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank and the World Trade Organization (WTO). While Globalization was making its effects felt in the whole world, the 1990s were dominated by the Washington Consensus , which imposed a series of Neo-liberal economic reforms in Latin America. The First Summit Of The Americas , held in Miami in 1994, resolved to establish a Free Trade Area Of The Americas (ALCA, ''Área de Libre Comercio de las Américas'') by 2005. The ALCA was supposed to be the generalization of the NAFTA Free-trade agreement between Canada, the US and Mexico, which came into force in 1994. Opposition to both NAFTA and ALCA was symbolized during this time by the Zapatista Army Of National Liberation insurrection, headed by Subcomandante Marcos , which became active on the day that NAFTA went into force (January 1st, 1994) and declared itself to be in explicit opposition to the ideology of globalization or neoliberalism, which NAFTA symbolized. 2000S: LEFT SURGE? , Secretary General of the OEA from 2004 to 2005, (center) and Samuel Lewis Navarro , Vice-President and Foreign Minister of Panama, (right) applaud former Chilean Interior Minister José Miguel Insulza (left) as the newly elected Secretary General Of The OEA in May 2005.]] The political context evolved again in the 2000s, with the election in several South American countries of left-wing governments. This "pink tide" thus saw the successive elections of '', 23/06/2005 ), are seen as more centered. The state of Bolivia also has seen some friction with Brazil, while Chile has historically followed its own policy, distinct from other South American countries and closer to the United States. Thus, Nouriel Roubini , professor of economics at New York University , declared in a May 2006 interview: "''"On one side, you have a number of administrations that are committed to moderate economic reform. On the other, you've had something of a backlash against the Washington Consensus set of liberal economic policies that Washington-based institutions urged Latin American countries to follow, including privatization, trade liberalization and fiscal discipline and some emergence of populist leaders."'' Bolivia's Nationalization of Oil and Gas , US Council On Foreign Relations , May 12, 2006 In the same way, although a Populist leader such as Chávez verbally attacks the George W. Bush Administration as much as the latter attacks him, and claims to be following a " Democratic Socialist " " Bolivarian Revolution ", the Geo-political Context has changed a lot since the 1970s. Larry Birns , director of the Council On Hemispheric Affairs , thus stated: "'' and Michael Lettieri , '' Political Affairs Magazine '', July 5, 2006 One sign of the US setback in the region has been the OEA 2005 Secretary General Election . For the first time in the OEA's history, Washington's candidate was refused by the majority of countries, after two stale-mate between José Miguel Insulza , member of the Socialist Party Of Chile (PS) and former Interior Minister of the latter country, and Luis Ernesto Derbez , member of the conservative National Action Party (PAN) and former Foreign Minister of Mexico. Derbez was explicitly supported by the US, Canada, Mexico, Belize, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Bolivia (then presided by Carlos Mesa ), Costa Rica, El Salvador, Honduras and Nicaragua, while Chilean minister José Insulza was supported by all the Southern Cone countries, as well as Brazil, Ecuador, Venezuela and the Dominican Republic. José Insulza was finally elected at the third turn, and took office on May 26 , 2005 . Free-trade and others regional integration While the , the United States, which had signed two free-trade agreements with Latin American countries, signed eight further agreements, reaching a total of ten such bilateral agreements (including the United States-Chile Free Trade Agreement in 2003, the Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement in 2006, etc.). Three others, including the Peru-United States Free Trade Agreement signed in 2006, are waiting for ratification by the US Congress '' Le Figaro '', 8 March 2007, George Bush défie Hugo Chavez sur son terrain . The Cuzco Declaration , signed a few weeks before at the Third South American Summit , announced the foundation of the Union Of South American Nations (Unasul-Unasur) grouping Mercosul countries and the Andean Community and which as the aim of eliminating Tariffs for non-sensitive products by 2014 and sensitive products by 2019. On the other hand, the CAFTA-DR free-trade agreement (Dominican Republic–Central America Free Trade Agreement) was ratified by all countries except Costa Rica . The president of the latter country, Óscar Arias , member of the National Liberation Party and Elected In February 2006 , has pronounced himself in favor of the agreement. Canada , which also has a free-trade agreement with Costa Rica, has also been negotiating such an agreement with Central American country, named Canada Central American Free Trade Agreement . On the other hand, Chile, which has long followed a policy differing from that of its neighbours, has signed the Trans-Pacific Strategic Economic Partnership (aka P4 free-trade agreement) with Brunei , New Zealand and Singapore . The P4 came into force in May 2006. All signatory countries are member of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum. Bilateral investment treaties Apart of binational free-trade agreements, the US have also signed a number of Bilateral Investment Treaties (BIT) with Latin American countries, establishing the conditions of Foreign Direct Investment . These treaties include "fair and equitable treatment", protection from Expropriation , free transfer of means and full protection and security. In case of a disagreement between a multinational firm and a state over some kind of investment made in a Latin American country, the firm may depose a lawsuit before the ICSID (International Center for the Resolution of Investment Disputes), which is an international court depending of the World Bank . Such a lawsuit was deposed by the US-based multinational firm '', URL accessed on 14 March 2007 . Such BIT were passed between the US and numerous countries (the given date is not of signature but of entrance in force of the treaty): Argentina (1994), Bolivia (2001), Ecuador (1997), Grenada (1989), Honduras (2001), Jamaica (1997), Panama (1991, amended in 2001), Trinidad and Tobago (1996). Others where signed but not ratified: El Salvador (1999), Haiti (1983 - one of the earliest, preceded by Panama), Nicaragua (1995). The ALBA See Also: Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas In reply to the ALCA, Chavez initiated the '', September 18, 2005, mirrored by Common Dreams . The US military coalition in Iraq However, the for Triple Canopy, paid half price in comparison to North-American employees. The news also attracted attention in Chile, when it became known that retired military Marina Óscar Aspe worked for Triple Canopy. The latter had taken part to the assassination of Marcelo Barrios Andrade, a 21 years-old member of the FPMR , who is on the list of victims of the Rettig Report — while Marina Óscar Aspe is on the list of the '' 2001 Comisión Ética Contra La Tortura '' (2001 Ethical Commission Against Torture). Triple Canopy also has a subsidiary in Peru . Bolivia's nationalization of natural resources , which lead to the resignation of US-supported The U.S. Department Of State issued a statement on October 13 declaring its support for Gonzalo Sánchez De Lozada , calling for "Bolivia's political leaders publicly express their support for democratic and constitutional order. The international community and the United States will not tolerate any interruption of constitutional order and will not support any regime that results from undemocratic means." This statement followed the death of 60 Bolivians during the police and army repression, in particular in El Alto , the Aymara suburb of La Paz 2 president Gonzalo Sanchez De Losada and the subsequent election of Evo Morales , first Aymara president of Bolivia and opponent of US sponsored Coca Eradication programs. ] The struggle for natural ressources and the US defense of its commercial interests has not ceases a single instant since the zenith period of the Banana Republic s supported by the US. But the general context has changed a lot, and each country's approach has much evolved. Thus, the Bolivian Gas War in 2003-04 was sparked after projects by the Pacific LNG consortium to export Natural Gas — Bolivia possessing the second largest natural gas reserves in South America after Venezuela — to California ('' Baja California '' and US California ) via Chile, ressented in Bolivia since the War Of The Pacific (1879-1884) which deprived it of an access to the Pacific Ocean . The ALCA was also opposed during the demonstrations, headed by the Bolivian Workers' Center and Felipe Quispe 's Indigenous Pachakuti Movement (MIP). The US also opposed Chávez, quickly recognizing the government of Pedro Carmona during the 2002 Coup Attempt which briefly overthrew him. A proof of the new geopolitical context can be seen in Evo Morales' announcement, in concordance with his electoral promises, of the and Michael Lettieri , '' Political Affairs Magazine '', July 5, 2006 . However, still according to Larry Birns , "The nationalization’s high media profile could force the {Link without Title} State Department to take a tough approach to the region, even to the point of mobilizing the CIA and the U.S. military, but it is more likely to work its way by undermining the all-important chink in the armor – the Latin American armed forces." US presence in the Triple Frontier The Argentine film called '' Sed, Invasión Gota A Gota '' ("Thirst, Invasion Drop by Drop"), directed by Mausi Martínez, portrays the Military Of The United States as slowly but steadily increasing its presence in the '' Triple Frontera '' (Triple Frontier, the area around the common borders of Paraguay, Argentina and Brazil). The overt reason for the increasing presence of U.S. troops and joint exercises, mainly with Paraguay, is to monitor the large Arab population which resides in the area. However, Martínez alleges that it is the water of the Guarani Aquifer which brings the Americans to the area, and she fears a subtle takeover before the local governments even realize what is going on. Similar concerns were lifted following both the signature of a military training agreement with Paraguay, which accorded immunity to U.S. soldiers from prosecution by the '', the U.S. military base is strategic because of its location near the Triple Frontier, its proximity to the Guaraní Aquifer, and its closeness to Bolivia (less than 200 km) at the same "moment that Washington's magnifying glass goes on the '' Altiplano '' and points toward Venezuela n [president Hugo Chávez — the regional devil according to the Bush Administration — as the instigator of the instability in the region" (''El Clarín'' ). In October 2006 , US President George W. Bush was reported to be negotiating for purchase of a 400 km&2 ranch near Marriscal Estigarribia 7 8. But Paraguay decided in October 2006 not to renew the immunity granted to US soldiers. The other members of the '', October 3, 2006 . REFERENCES SEE ALSO
Binational relationships
|
|
|