| Historical Criticism In Bible Studies |
Article Index for Historical |
Website Links For Historical |
Information AboutHistorical Criticism In Bible Studies |
| CATEGORIES ABOUT HISTORICAL CRITICISM IN BIBLE STUDIES | |
| biblical criticism | |
| higher criticism | |
|
This term is used in contrast with Lower Criticism (or textual criticism), the endeavour to determine what a text originally said before it was altered (through error or intent). HIGHER CRITICISM AND RADICAL CRITICISM Higher criticism originally referred to the work of German Biblical scholars, of the Tübingen School . After the path-breaking work on the New Testament by Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768–1834), the next generation which included scholars such as David Friedrich Strauss (1808–74) and Ludwig Feuerbach (1804–72) in the mid- Nineteenth Century analyzed the historical records of the Middle East from Christian and Old Testament times in search of independent confirmation of events related in the Bible . These latter scholars built on the tradition of Enlightenment and Rationalist thinkers such as John Locke , David Hume , Immanuel Kant , Gotthold Lessing , Gottlieb Fichte , Georg Hegel and the French Rationalists . These ideas were imported to England by Samuel Taylor Coleridge and, in particular, by George Eliot 's translations of Strauss's '' Life Of Jesus '' (1846) and Feuerbach's '' Essence Of Christianity '' (1854). In 1860 seven Liberal Anglican theologians began the process of incorporating this historical criticism into Christian doctrine in '' Essays And Reviews '', causing a five year storm of controversy which completely overshadowed the arguments over Darwin's newly published '' On The Origin Of Species ''. Two of the authors were indicted for heresy and lost their jobs by 1862, but in 1864 had the judgement overturned on appeal. '' La Vie De Jésus '' (1863), the seminal work by a Frenchman, Ernest Renan (1823–92), continued in the same tradition as Strauss and Feuerbach. In Catholicism, '' L'Evangile Et L'Eglise '' (1902), the magnum opus by Alfred Loisy against the '' Essence Of Christianity '' of Adolf Von Harnack and ''La Vie de Jesus'' of Renan, gave birth to the Modernist Crisis (1902–61). Some scholars, such as Rudolf Bultmann , have used higher criticism of the Bible to " Demythologize " it. Radical Criticism , around the end of the nineteenth century, typically tried to show that none of the Pauline epistles are authentic; that Paul is nothing but a controverted authorial token. This group of scholars often postulated the ahistoricity of Jesus and the apostles. RECEPTION OF HIGHER CRITICISM BY RELIGIOUS ADHERENTS The questions of higher criticism are widely recognized by Orthodox Jews and many traditional Christians as legitimate questions, yet they often find the answers given by the higher critics unsatisfactory or even Heretical . In particular, religious conservatives object to the Rationalistic and Naturalistic presuppositions of a large number of practitioners of higher criticism that lead to conclusions that conservative religionists find unacceptable. Nonetheless, conservative Bible scholars practice their own form of higher criticism within their supernaturalist and confessional frameworks. In contrast, other biblical scholars believe that the evidence uncovered by higher criticism undermines such confessional frameworks. In addition, religiously Liberal Christians and religiously liberal Jews typically maintain that belief in God has nothing to do with the authorship of the Pentateuch . HIGHER CRITICISM OF OTHER RELIGIOUS TEXTS Both higher and lower forms of criticism are carried out today with the religious writings of many religions, including Hinduism , Buddhism and Confucianism . ISLAM Modern higher criticism is just beginning for the Qur'an . This scholarship questions some traditional claims about its composition and content, contending that the Qur'an incorporates material from both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament ; however, other scholars argue that it cites examples from previous texts, as the New Testament did to the Old Testament. For example, Islamic history records that Uthman collected all variants of the Qur'an and destroyed those that he did not approve of. FINDINGS OF HIGHER CRITICISM Scholars of higher criticism have sometimes upheld and sometimes challenged the traditional authorship of various books of the Bible. SEE ALSO Types of higher criticism
History of higher criticism EXTERNAL LINKS
|
|
|