| Higher Criticism |
Website Links For Method |
Information AboutHigher Criticism |
|
The historical-critical method, also sometimes called the '''scientific-critical method''', is a broad term that includes numerous methodologies and strategies for understanding ancient Manuscripts , especially the Bible . and Higher Criticism . The historical critical method "studies the biblical text in the same fashion as it would study any other ancient text and comments upon it as an expression of human discourse". Interpretation of the Bible TYPES OF HISTORICAL-CRITICAL METHODS Lower criticism None of the original books of the New Testament have survived to modern times. All that exists are copies of these original documents. Since they often do not match, lower criticism was developed to find what the original looked like. For example, Josephus employed Scribe s to copy his '' Antiquities Of The Jews ''. As the scribes copied the ''Antiquities'', they made mistakes. The copies of these copies also had the mistakes. Each generation of copies contained errors, but not necessarily more than the previous generation as errors would be fixed when caught by scribes. When an error consists of something being left out, it is called a deletion. When something was added, it is called an interpolation. Today, none of Josephus' original work survives, but different families of texts have survived. Lower Criticism studies these surviving families, particularly the differences among them. Scholars are then able to piece together what the original looked like. The more surviving copies, the more accurately they can piece together the original. Lower criticism is applied to understanding the source documents of the Historical Jesus . Higher criticism Once lower critics have done their job and we have a good idea of what the original text looked like, higher critics can then compare this text with the writing of other authors. Scholars try to understand whether the author is an eyewitness to Jesus, or whether he is basing his work on primary or even secondary sources. They also try to understand the bias of the writer, which will give us hints to why he focuses on one aspect of Jesus' life but omits another. An example of higher criticism at work would be the study of the . Today, most higher critical scholars believe that Luke edited three sources: Mark, the Q Document , and Proto-Luke into the Canonical Lukean Gospel. They do not agree on the nature of Proto-Luke ATTITUDES TO THE HISTORICAL-CRITICAL METHOD Roman Catholic view The Catholic Church uses Catholic historical-critical methods as a required approach to interpreting sacred scripture based on the Magisterium recommendations found in Divino Afflante Spiritu and Dei Verbum . The modern Catechism states that #110 ''"In order to discover the sacred authors' intention, the reader must take into account the conditions of their time and culture, the literary genres in use at that time, and the modes of feeling, speaking and narrating then current. "For the fact is that truth is differently presented and expressed in the various types of historical writing, in prophetical and poetical texts, and in other forms of literary expression."'' The Church Father St. Augustine used the historical-critical method stating that we must take into consideration the time at which anything was enjoyed or allowed. This position is quoted by Dei Verbum which is referenced by the Catechism. Patrologia Latina records the tradition of this method J.P. Migne, ed., Patroligia Latina(Paris, 1841-1855) 34, 75-76. Father Raymond E. Brown was an American Roman Catholic priest and Biblical scholar who was one of the leading proponents of the historical-critical method. With Divino Afflante Spiritu , Pope Pius XII reversed a trend in Catholic biblical scholarship, which had begun toward the end of Leo XIII's pontificate, developed under Pius X, and was reinforced under Benedict XV, at least in regard to historical criticism.Fogarty, page 240. Pope Leo XIII's encyclical ''Providentissimus Deus'' called higher criticism an "inept method".Fogarty, page 40. SEE ALSO
FOOTNOTES REFERENCES
EXTERNAL LINKS
|
|
|