| Fictional Beings And Reference Failure |
Article Index for Fictional |
Website Links For Fictional |
Information AboutFictional Beings And Reference Failure |
| CATEGORIES ABOUT FICTIONAL BEINGS AND REFERENCE FAILURE | |
| philosophy of language | |
|
Distinguishing between fictional statements and false statements According to the Russellian theory of reference, the statement “ Long John Silver has a wooden leg” and the statement “ Earth's Moon has a diameter of 2856 kilometers” are equally false. The first statement suffers reference failure, because it fails to pick out an individual in the actual world. The second sentence refers to an object in the actual world, but the predicate does not obtain in the actual world. Russell's theory thus does not assign different truth-values to the two statements.ISBN 0674299663 True and false statements in fiction In the Russellian system, the statement “Long John Silver has a wooden leg” and the statement “Long John Silver was one of the most successful playwrights of late Victorian London” have the same truth value: false. This equality may present problems for those wishing to distinguish such statements in terms of truth value.ISBN 0674299663 Other problem cases: real referents in fictional worlds Some statements are false with reference to the actual world but potentially true in reference to some fictional world. ISBN 0674299663 Coleridge's “In Xanadu did Kubla Khan a stately pleasure-dome decree” does not, strictly speaking, suffer reference failure. The 18th century version of the name Kublai Khan picks out the Mongol Emperor, the grandson of Genghis Khan. But since few of the events in Coleridge's narrative poem obtain in the actual world, according to Russellian logic, most statements in the poem are false. REFERENCES |
|
|