Holden V. Hardy Article Index for
Holden
Website Links For
Holden
 

Information About

Holden V. Hardy




  Court Supreme Court of the United States
  Decided-date February 28, 1898
  Full-case-name Holden v Hardy, Sheriff
  Citations 169 US 366
  Prior-history Writ of habeas corpus denied Holden remanded to custody of Sheriff Hardy
  Subsequent-history None
  Holding Laws limiting working hours in mines and smelters are a legitimate, constitutional exercise of the state police power, given the inherent danger of such work
  Chief-justice Melville Weston Fuller
  Majority-by Henry B Brown
  Dissent Brewer and Peckham
  Laws-applied US Const Amend XIV, Utah state law


In ''Holden v. Hardy'' the Supreme Court Of The United States upholds a Utah state law limiting the number of work hours for miners and smelters as a legitimate exercise of the police power. The majority holds that such a law is legitimate, provided that there is indeed a rational basis, supported by facts, for the legislature to believe particular laws are dangerous. The court was quick to distinguish this from other cases of the era which imposed universal maximum hour rules, which it held unconstitutional under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment .