Pantheism

HISTORY

The term "pantheist" — of which the word "pantheism" is a variation — was purportedly first used by Irish Writer John Toland in his 1705 work, '' Socinianism Truly Stated, by a pantheist''. However, the concept has been discussed as far back as the time of the philosophers of Ancient Greece . Some, such as Heraclitus , debated whether the entire substance of the universe was a force of '' Logos '' and/or ''agon'', of thought and the world in a constant state of transformative conflict.

In 1785 a major controversy began between Friedrich Jacobi and Moses Mendelssohn , which eventually involved many important people of the time. Jacobi claimed that Lessing 's pantheism was materialistic in that it thought of all Nature and God as one extended Substance . For Jacobi, this was the result of the Enlightenment 's devotion to Reason and it would lead to Atheism . Mendelssohn disagreed by asserting that pantheism was the same as theism.

VARIETIES OF PANTHEISM

This article distinguishes between two divergent groups of pantheists:

Classical Pantheism , which is expressed in the Immanent God of Kabalistic Judaism , Advaita Vedanta Sanatana Dharma , and Monism , generally viewing God in a personal manner.

Naturalistic Pantheism , based on the relatively recent views of Baruch Spinoza and John Toland (who coined the term "pantheism"), as well as contemporary influences.

The vast majority of persons who can be identified as "pantheistic" are of the classical variety (such as Hindus ), while most persons who self-identify as "pantheist" alone (rather than as members of another religion) are of the naturalistic variety. The division between the two "flavours" of pantheism is not entirely clear in all situations, and remains a source of some controversy in pantheist circles. Classical pantheists generally accept the religious doctrine that there is a spiritual basis to all reality, while naturalistic pantheists generally do not and thus see the world in scientific terms.

METHODS OF EXPLANATION

An oft-cited feature of pantheism is that each individual human, being part of the universe or nature, is part of God. One issue discussed by pantheists is how, if this is so, humans can have free will. In answer, the following analogy is sometimes given (particularly by classical pantheists): "you are to God as an Individual Blood Cell in your Vein is to you." The analogy further maintains that while a cell may be aware of its own environs, and even has some choices ( Free Will ) between right and wrong (killing a Bacterium , becoming Malignant , or perhaps just doing nothing, among countless others), it likely has little conception of the greater being of which it is a part. Another way to understand this relationship is the Hindu concept of Jiva , wherein the human Soul is an aspect of God not yet having reached enlightenment ( Moksha ), after which it becomes Atman .

However, it should be noted that not all pantheists accept the idea of free will, with Determinism being particularly widespread among naturalistic pantheists. Although individual interpretations of pantheism may suggest certain implications for the nature and existence of free will and/or determinism, pantheism itself does not include any requirement of belief either way. However, the issue is widely discussed, as it is in many other religions and philosophies.

DEBATE

Some critics argue that pantheism is little more than a redefinition of the word "God" to mean " Existence ", " Life " or " Reality ". Many pantheists reply that even if this is so, such a shift in the way we think about these ideas can serve to create both a new and a potentially far more insightful conception of both existence and God.

Perhaps the most significant debate within the pantheistic community is about the nature of God. Classical Pantheism believes in a personal, Conscious , and Omniscient God, and sees this God as uniting all true religions. Naturalistic Pantheism believes in an unconscious, non-sentient universe, which, while being holy and beautiful, is seen as being a God in a non-traditional and impersonal sense.

Cosmotheism , a small but controversial Racialist group which considers itself a form of pantheism, has an evolutionary interpretation of God, seeing God to be impersonal, but not taking a clear stance as to it's Sentience . “Cosmotheism”, like the terms “pantheism”, “monotheism”, and “polytheism”, was not used in antiquity. The term seems to have been coined by Lamoignon De Malesherbes in 1782 with regard to Pliny The Elder ; various scholars have used it since then, but to refer to different sorts of religious belief.

The viewpoints encompassed within the pantheistic community are necessarily diverse, but the central idea of the universe being an all-encompassing unity and the sanctity of both nature and its natural laws are found throughout. Some pantheists also posit a common purpose for nature and man, while others reject the idea of purpose and view existence as existing "for its own sake."

RELATED CONCEPTS

Panentheism

Pantheism has features in common with Panentheism , such as the idea that the universe is part of God. Technically, the two are separate, inasmuch as pantheism finds God synonymous with nature, and panentheism finds God to be greater than nature alone. Some find this distinction unhelpful, while others see it as a significant point of division. Many of the major faiths described as pantheistic could also be described as panentheistic, whereas naturalistic pantheism cannot (not seeing God as more than nature alone). For example, elements of both panentheism and pantheism are found in Hinduism. Certain interpretations of the Bhagavad Gita and Shri Rudram support this view.

Cosmotheism

While the term is rarely used, and is most often simply a synonym for Pantheism, this unusual philosophy has been used rather differently, but in all cases, the feeling was that God was something created by man, perhaps even an end state of Human Evolution , through social planning, eugenics and other forms of genetic engineering.

) and there were also some sections of his great work '' Outline Of History '', which reflected this belief and his finding it in the teachings of Jesus Christ and Siddhartha . His book ''Shape of Things to Come'' (and the 1936 film '' Things To Come '') also reflects this, in which mankind, surviving a Nuclear war and an extended Feudal period, unites to form a collectivist Utopia .

In modern Israel , Cosmotheism was described by Mordekhay Nesiyahu , one of the foremost ideologists of the Israeli Labor Movement and a lecturer in its college Beit Berl . He felt that God was something which did not exist before man, and was a secular entity which the rebuilding Jewish Temple In Jerusalem has an instrumental role in "invent {Link without Title} " God.

In the , Francis Galton and Theosophy ).

Vladimir Vernadsky 's and Pierre Teilhard De Chardin 's " Noosphere " could be referenced as a description of the Cosmotheist deity, as does Emile Durkheim 's Collective Consciousness and Carl Jung 's Collective Unconscious .

Arthur C. Clark makes a possible reference to the Cosmotheist Noosphere in his 1953 book '' Childhood's End '', referring to it as the "Overmind".

PANTHEISTIC CONCEPTS IN RELIGION

Hinduism

In Hindu Theology Moksha and achieving godness is The Ultimate , both Transcendent and Immanent , the Absolute Infinite Existence , the sum total of all that ever is, was, or ever shall be. As the sun has rays of light which emanate from the same source, the same holds true for the multifaceted aspects of God emanating from Brahman, like many colors of the same prism. This concept of God is of one unity, with the individual personal Gods being aspects of the One; thus, different deities are seen by different adherents as particularly well suited to their worship. Pantheism and panentheism are key components of Advaita theology.

In Smartist tradition, which follows Advaita philosophy, Brahman is seen as the one God, with aspects of God emanating therefrom. With all Hindus, there is a strong belief in all paths, or true religions, leading to One God.

Some of the Hindu aspects of God include Ganesa , Devi , Vishnu , and Siva .

Hindus who follow the Smarta tradition believe that these different aspects of God can bring worshippers closer to Moksha , end of the Cycle Of Rebirth .

Other subdivisions of Vedanta do not strictly hold this tenet. For example, Dvaita school of Madhva holds Brahman to be only Vishnu . In contrast, Arya Samaj believes in worshipping Brahman directly, without conceptualizing God through form such as Ishta-deva or using an Icon , the Hindu Murti to focus. Arya Samaj only takes into consideration the formless Brahman while Advaita states that the formless Brahman ( Nirguna Brahman ) and the formful God Saguna Brahman are the same and hence worship of either is valid and equivalent.
However, Advaita agrees with Arya Samaj that the Ultimate Reality is attributeless, in contrast to the theistic schools of Ramanuja , who also stressed panentheism, and Madhva , an advocate of Duality .

Vedanta , specifically, Advaita , is a branch of Hindu Philosophy which gives this matter a greater focus. Most Vedantic adherents are Monists or "non- Dualists " (i.e. Advaita Vedanta ), seeing multiple manifestations of the one God or source of being, a view which is often confused by non-Hindus as being Polytheistic .

Judaism

The radically Immanent sense of the divine in Jewish mystical Kabbalah is said to have inspired Spinoza's formulation of pantheism. However Spinoza's views have not been accepted in Judaism. Additionally, the Baal Shem Tov , the founder of Hasidism , had a mystical sense of the divine that could be described as Panentheism .

Christian

From the tiny groups such as Process Theology and Creation Spirituality , up to the Liberal Catholic Church , and as far back into history as the Brethren Of The Free Spirit and many Gnostic s, the idea has had currency within some segments of Christianity for some time.

Islam

Islamic Sufism is regarded by some as being influenced by eastern philosophies (Indian and Persian) and has Pantheistic doctrines within its many varieties.

Other religions

There are many elements of pantheism in Philosophical Taoism , some forms of Buddhism , and Theosophy along with many varying denominations and individuals within and without denominations.

Many Unitarian Universalists consider themselves pantheists.

Paul Carus called himself "an atheist who loves God", and advocated " Henism ", which is often seen as Monist or Pantheist in nature.

QUOTATIONS

While Sagan never described himself as a pantheist, many maintain that pantheism fit his views better than any other term. This claim, while widely accepted among pantheists of all varieties, remains somewhat controversial outside the pantheist community. A similar debate surrounds the attribution of pantheism to other notable figures, including Albert Einstein .

Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677) established the formal philosophy of Pantheism over 300 years ago. In his “Ethics” he wrote:

Albert Einstein appeared to agree with Spinoza when he said:

SEE ALSO